THESE BIRDS WALK Review

Courtesy of Oscilloscope Laboratories

THESE BIRDS WALK

2013, 72 minutes

Not Rated

Review by Joshua Handler

Omar Mullick and Bassam Tariq's moving documentary These Birds Walk tells the stories of an ambulance driver, Asad, and a runaway boy, Omar, in Karachi, Pakistan.  These Birds Walk is a documentary that will likely not get the attention it deserves, which is a shame given that a big film with no right to exist will draw audiences by the droves this weekend.  

While These Birds Walk is far too short at 72 minutes, it packs a big emotional punch due to the heart-wrenching subject matter.  Omar's scenes are by far the highlight of the film and the reason I wished that this film had run longer.  While we get to know both Omar and Asad over the course of the film, I wish I had gotten more time with them.  They are fascinating subjects from very troubled homes.  When Omar is on screen doing something as mundane as talking with friends, it is interesting.  At the beginning of the film, he is talking with his friend, Shehr, at the shelter they're staying at.  Sheher is the reason why life is bearable at the shelter for Omar.  At one point during this conversation, Omar does something that makes Sheher sad and upon realizing this, Omar hugs Sheher and says, "Don't cry. You're my little brother."  This little moment is so impactful because it shows the deep love that these two have for each other and shows the depth of their relationship.  

These Birds Walk is beautifully shot and tightly edited, but again, I wish it was longer.  There is so much to explore and so much more that I would have liked to see, such as more scenes of Asad.  While Asad has his fair share of screen time, I wish he had more because there are brief moments in the film where he discusses his past, which are illuminating.  

Overall, These Birds Walk is a gripping documentary that should please just about anyone who goes to see it.  Its lack of sentimentality is admirable and shows that the material is powerful enough to ellicit enough emotion on its own.  

3/4

BASTARDS Review

Photo credit:  Camille DE CHENAY

© 2013 ALCATRAZ FILMS / WILD BUNCH / ARTE FRANCE CINEMA / PANDORA PRODUKTION

BASTARDS 

2013, 96 minutes

Not Rated

Review by Joshua Handler

Claire Denis' Bastards is quite the film - fragmented, nasty, bleak, and inaccessible.  It doesn't always work due to the fragmented structure and conventional story, but it does have enough strong performances, intrigue, and disturbing scenes to keep it interesting.

The film tells the story of Marco Silvestri (Vincent Lindon), a man who returns from sea to deal with some family issues which turn out to be far more disturbing than he ever imagined.

The less you know about Bastards the better.  While none of the twists are earth-shattering, they are still interesting and knowing little helps.  The final sequences of this film are what make it as powerful and as disturbing as it is.  They are thrilling and they hammer home Denis' dark worldview.  The final shots are brilliant and disturbing on multiple levels.  Bastards is a perfect title for this film as almost everyone is a bastard.  Marco is a good man, but no one else around him is.  The ending shows just how how horrible everyone is and ends the film on a disturbing, bleak note.  This finale contains some electrifying music by Tindersticks (the entire score is fantastic), which adds to the film moody atmosphere.

The acting by everyone is very good, but Vincent Lindon is the highlight in the lead.  His performance is subtly commanding.  He makes Marco a tough, but sympathetic character, as he is the only character in the film who isn't despicable.

As compelling as much of Bastards is, the fragmented structure really hurts it, as it makes the film very hard to follow and lessens the impact of some scenes that could have been very disturbing and memorable.

Overall, Bastards is a good film hurt by a muddled narrative.  Many will be put off by its bleak worldview and relentless nature, but those two things will be the reason why many others will love it.  I liked this film and would recommend it to arthouse cinema fans who like their movies dark.

3/4

BLUE IS THE WARMEST COLOR (LA VIE D'ADÉLE) Review

Emma (Léa Seydoux) and Adele (Adèle Exarchopoulos) © 2013 WILD BUNCH, QUAT’SOUS FILMS, FRANCE 2 CINEMA, SCOPE PICTURES, VERTIGO FILMS    

BLUE IS THE WARMEST COLOR (LA VIE D'ADÈLE)

2013, 179 minutes

Rated NC-17 for explicit sexual content

Review by Joshua Handler

This film is such a knockout, such a revelation, such a gut punch that it was hard to believe I was simply watching a movie.  Director Abdellatif Kechiche shot this film in a cinéma vérité style, which makes everything look natural.  All cinematic touches have been eliminated and what's left is a raw, realistic look at a tragic romance.  

Adèle (Adèle Exarchopoulos) is a high school student who finds her relationship with her boyfriend unsatisfactory.  One day, Adèle passes a young, blue-haired woman, Emma (Léa Seydoux) in the street and is transfixed.  Soon after, Adèle’s friend takes her to a gay bar.  Upon leaving the gay bar and following the blue-haired girl to another bar, Adèle finally meets Emma.  This marks the beginning of a passionate, but doomed relationship that the film follows from the beginning to the end.  

Ever since premiering at Cannes in May and winning the Palme d'Or, Blue is the Warmest Color has been stirring up controversy with its seven minute-long sex scene and its actresses speaking out against Kechiche's working habits.  Do yourself a favor a put all of that aside for three hours because this movie is so much more than a few graphic sex scenes.  

Blue is the Warmest Color finds its greatest strength in the performances of Adèle Exarchopoulos and Léa Seydoux who, for the first time in history, were awarded the Palme d'Or along with the director.  Exarchopoulos and Seydoux's chemistry is beyond believable.  It is frightening to think that they were not actually in love with one another.  

Watching Blue was like reliving first love all over again.  The most effective moments in Blue are those small human moments that exist in the context of longer scenes.  At 179 minutes, this movie is long, but the length is justified because Kechiche finds the small moments of human beauty in the midst of his extended scenes.  Take, for example, a scene early in the relationship in which Adèle and Emma are enjoying a day lying on the grass in the park.  They talk, but it is the quiet moments, not the talk, that matter.  Each loving glance shows Adèle or Emma desperately wanting to know everything about the other and simply live inside the other to know what exactly the other is thinking at any given moment.  The epic lust for knowledge about the other person that exists during the honeymoon period of any relationship is seen in the eyes of these characters and Kechiche captures it perfectly without any self-awareness.

This approach works for this film because it makes the beauty feel natural.  The average film finds the moments of beauty in each scene and cuts out everything else to create a world of beauty, of heightened reality.  Reality isn’t heightened in Kechiche’s world – it is restored.  Blue is the Warmest Color looks so realistic that it feels like a documentary.

For all of the pleasure and love portrayed in the film, there is quite a bit of pain, particularly during the wrenching third hour.  Everything is wonderful until the inevitable downturn in the relationship.  These scenes sting.  I felt the pain of the young women as they suffered, which made the movie that much more emotional.  The first two hours of Blue are very good, but it is the final hour that brings everything home and makes the film the heartbreaking masterwork that it is.

Kechiche, by shooting this film vérité style, allows scenes to run long.  These scenes unfold like life.  Kechiche doesn't always use these scenes so much to develop the actual plot as to develop the emotional arc of Adèle   Adèle wishes to be a teacher and in the latter part of the film, she is.  There are many scenes of Adèle teaching.  These scenes don't always move the plot forward, but they always show of Adèle's emotional state.  Kechiche doesn't seem to respect or disrespect his characters.  He allows his actors to make us care and respect them.

Much of the reason Blue is such a towering success is because of the performances of its actresses, Exarchopoulos in particular.  They give performances that defy description.  Their performances go beyond acting and are, without exaggeration, two of the greatest performances in the history of cinema.  Exarchopoulos is Adèle.  Never once during the duration of the film’s 179-minute running time did her performance ever feel forced.  I cannot do her performance justice by writing about it – just see the movie and you’ll know what I mean.

Léa Seydoux is the perfect match for Exarchopoulos.  She is sexy, alluring, and passionate.  In her scenes with Exarchopoulos, sparks fly and she lights up the screen.  As with Exarchopoulos, words cannot do her performance justice.

Overall, Blue is the Warmest Color is a journey through love unlike any other.  By the end of the film, I felt as if I lived with Adèle and Emma through their years-long relationship.  Blue is (literally and figurately) a naked exploration of passion and love and one of the most beautiful romances I’ve ever seen.  Kechiche and his actors have created a completely pure love story that will touch everyone who has experienced first love.  Blue will especially speak to those in the process of coming out.  It could be a cathartic and liberating experience to view this film.  It celebrates the ups and downs of life and love in a straightforward, honest manner and through this film and its honesty, we see ourselves and learn.  Blue is the Warmest Color epitomizes what makes cinema great.

4/4